Check your card and how it connects
Make sure your card is an OpenPGP smartcard with ECC support, and that NFC is on if you'll tap it. A USB-C key such as the YubiKey 5C goes in the USB-C port instead; it can't be tapped. PGPony's on-card generation was validated on the YubiKey 5 NFC and Token2. RSA-only cards can't hold the Ed25519 / Curve25519 keys PGPony generates.